Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Matt Gardenghi's avatar

Awesome work. Thank you.

I love that you all work so well together. I'm waiting for the book/tv show/movie which frames husband and wife as a team against the world, instead of a couple at odds with each other until the end of the story.

Been doing a bit of reading of late on adjacent subjects like Carl Truman's the Rise and Triumph of the Modern Self. You all might enjoy that work as it traces the modern view of self starting with the Greeks to the present.

As a husband and father, the most important lesson for me was to sacrifice my "needs" for the benefit of my wife and family. Well, that and deliberately structuring my house as a place that gives praise to our Savior and Creator. This fundamentally transforms the home for the better.

Thanks again.

Expand full comment
T. Greer's avatar

This is very interesting.

I think either you or the author you review discounts one other strain of anti-family/marriage thought in ancient Greece. The Greeks lionized the public at the expense of the private. The private was selfish; it was the world outside citizenship. It was, by definition, the realm of women, children, and slaves.

Greek myth is full of sons that eat fathers and mothers who murder children; <a href="https://antoniustetrax.substack.com/p/on-the-strangeness-of-the-greeks">it equates sex with violence and family with disorder.</a> The polis had no place for the family; honor, order, and law existed in and because of the public realm of the citizen. The Spartans take this logic to an extreme, but an extreme that was in turn idealized by other Greeks.

The first volume of Paul Rahe's REPUBLICS: ANCIENT AND MODERN is especially good on this, and can be read as a stand alone work: https://amzn.to/4dnWpFv

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts