Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Strange Ian's avatar

The "black tax" stuff happens in indigenous communities across northern Australia as well. The stories I've heard are like - you make some money by selling paintings, you buy a new fridge, your cousin walks into the house and takes it. You can't stop him because you have deeply baked-in family obligations and your culture has never had enough material wealth to develop a meaningful concept of "theft".

I'm from Brisbane and I know a few people who've done various health or social work type jobs across far north Australia and PNG. Pretty sure we're still just as confused about each other as we were in the days of the missionaries. The question of how to bridge the gap between a basically Palaeolithic culture and fully modern industrial capitalism remains very much alive, and politically tricky, since you're not supposed to say things like "a basically Palaeolithic culture".

One book I like a lot about this topic is Bill Bunbury's "It's Not The Money, It's The Land", about the imposition of minimum wage laws on Aboriginal cattle stockmen in Western Australia. Might only be of interest to Australians but I think it's a great study of how difficult it is to reconcile the Australian system of industrial relations with indigenous concepts of land and property. Two radically different modes of production directly colliding without being able to understand each other at all.

Expand full comment
Smaug's avatar

I am speechless after reading this. You make such an important point at the end. I will be thinking of this for a very long time. Thank you so much for writing this review.

Expand full comment
35 more comments...

No posts