Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Polynices's avatar

Wonderful review.

Expand full comment
wargamer's avatar

Fun topic and a fun review.

I read that Carthage book about 8 years ago and sadly I wasn't a fan. It felt like the author didn't have enough material to work with (understandable) and so he badly padded things out by adding a bunch of material on the pan-Mediterranean cult of Heracles throughout the book. That was kind of interesting but it also felt really off-topic.

What's Cline's take on what drove Egypt's long-term (permanent, it turns out) funk? The nature of their entire civilization seems like it should be able to survive a collapse like that of the Late Bronze Age, and they did, but then just...never really got it back together after that, even though Egypt was consistently a very rich part of whatever foreign conqueror managed to take it over.

Expand full comment
12 more comments...

No posts